“Incidental” inclusion of artistic work in a film or broadcast
May 2009
This information is for general guidance only; it is not legal advice.
Under Australian copyright law, you don’t need permission to include an
artistic work in a film or broadcast if it is “only incidental to the principal
matters represented in the film or broadcast”.
In most cases, items in the background – such as posters on walls, book
and CD covers, and labels on groceries – are likely to be incidental,
even if they were deliberately placed in a set. Similarly, it’s likely
that filming artworks that are included in footage as people walk
through a house or gallery, or as a result of someone being interviewed
in a room that has pictures on the wall, would also be regarded as
incidental and would not require permission under Australian law.
However, if the works are the subject of the film – for example, you’re
shooting a documentary about a painter or the subject of the film is an
art collection – reproduction of the works in the film could well fall
outside the exception and require permission. Similarly, permission is
likely to be needed to include a 1955 or later photo of James Dean or
Elvis Presley, for example, in a documentary about their lives, or in a
feature film whose central theme was a person who had an obsession with
such a figure.
As a rule of thumb, the more prominently an artistic work is featured
in a shot, and the more closely it is related to the subject of the
film, the less likely it is that filming would be regarded as
“incidental”.